Logo Dr. Jed Bouguila (MD-PhD)

Where will my scars be, and will they really show?

Dr. Jed Bouguila (MD-PhD)9 min read

There is no surgery without a scar. The whole art lies in placing the scar where it will be least visible, closing it without tension, and supporting it through the eighteen months it takes to mature. A patient who knows exactly where the scar will be and what it will look like at three months does not worry when it is red and firm: they know it is the normal stage.

Scar map, procedure by procedure

ProcedureLocationVisibility at 1 year
Closed rhinoplastyOnly inside the nostrilsNo visible scar
Open rhinoplastyA 4 to 5 mm line under the columella, between the nostrilsAlmost invisible from the front
Upper blepharoplastyIn the natural crease of the eyelidInvisible with eyes open
Lower blepharoplastyJust under the lashes, or from the inside with no external scarVery discreet
Otoplasty (ear pinning)Behind the ear, in the grooveHidden by the ear
Facelift and neck liftIn front of and behind the ear, extending into the hairHidden in skin folds and hair
Endoscopic forehead lift3 to 5 incisions of 1 to 2 cm in the hairInvisible
Buccal fat removalInside the mouthNo skin scar
Orthognathic (jaw) surgeryEntirely inside the mouthNo skin scar
Breast implantsA 4 to 5 cm scar in the breast fold, or along the lower edge of the areolaDiscreet, hidden when standing
Breast liftAround the areola + vertical down to the breast foldVisible when topless, fades with time
Breast reductionInverted T or vertical, depending on the volumeVisible when topless
Liposuction3 to 5 mm incisions in skin foldsMarks almost invisible
Tummy tuckLow horizontal scar from hip to hip + around the belly buttonHidden under standard underwear or a swimsuit
Arm lift (brachioplasty)Inner arm, from armpit to elbowVisible with arms raised
Hair transplantTiny dots in the donor area (FUE)Invisible with short hair
Location and usual visibility

The four phases, and why month three is the worst

A scar does not improve in a straight line. It gets worse first, then gets better. Many patients get alarmed at exactly the point where things are developing normally.

  1. Weeks 0 to 3 - closure. The scar is thin and pink, sometimes with scabs. It often looks very satisfying. Yet its mechanical strength is only about 20%: this is the period when it must not be pulled on.
  2. Weeks 3 to 12 - inflammation. The scar becomes red, thick, firm, sometimes raised and itchy. This is the stage that worries people, and it is the most normal one of all. It is also when care has the greatest effect.
  3. Months 3 to 12 - maturation. The redness fades, and the scar gradually softens, flattens and pales.
  4. Months 12 to 18 - final appearance. The scar becomes pearly white, soft and flat. Only at this stage can you judge the result and consider a possible revision.

Care that works, and care that is useless

What has proven effectiveness

  • Total sun protection, SPF 50+, for at least twelve months. This is the most important factor and the most neglected. A scar exposed to the sun while it matures becomes permanently pigmented, and this cannot be reversed. Covering it with clothing is not always enough: thin fabric lets UV through.
  • Silicone dressings and gels, once healing is complete, worn 12 to 23 hours a day for 2 to 3 months. This is the reference treatment to prevent thick scars.
  • Scar massage, once or twice a day, five to ten minutes, starting from the third week. It softens the scar, releases adhesions and reduces itching.
  • No tension. On the abdomen, breasts and arms, respecting the rest periods before exercise is what determines the final width of the scar.
  • For scars that are already thick: corticosteroid injections, vascular laser, sometimes compression. These are medical treatments, to be discussed at a check-up.

What has no proven benefit

  • Vitamin E applied to the skin: no proven benefit, and contact dermatitis in one in three cases in some studies.
  • Plant oils and shea butter: they moisturise, which is good, but have no effect on the scar itself. The massage that goes with them is useful, not the product.
  • Onion extract and non-silicone “anti-scar” creams: effectiveness not established.
  • Miracle supplements. A diet with enough protein, vitamin C and zinc is useful; mega-doses are not.

Why some people heal poorly

Some factors are out of your hands, others are entirely up to you. It is important to tell them apart.

FactorEffectModifiable
SmokingReduces oxygen supply to the wound edges, delays healing, and multiplies the risk of tissue death and wideningYes, and it is the most important one
Tension on the scarPermanent wideningYes, by respecting the rest periods
Sun exposurePermanent pigmentationYes
Dark skin typeHigher risk of hypertrophic scars or keloidsNo, but can be anticipated with intensified care
Personal history of keloidsFrequent recurrenceNo, but requires a specific strategy
High-risk areas (breastbone, shoulders, back, earlobe)Thicker scarsNo
Young ageStronger inflammatory reactionNo
Diabetes, malnutrition, long-term corticosteroidsDelayed healingPartly, by optimizing before surgery

Hypertrophic scar or keloid: how to tell them apart

  • Hypertrophic scar: thick and red, but it stays within the limits of the original incision. It improves on its own over 12 to 18 months, often faster with silicone and massage.
  • Keloid scar: it goes beyond the limits of the incision and invades healthy skin, with claw-like extensions. It does not regress on its own and needs active treatment. Simple excision without additional treatment almost certainly leads to recurrence, often larger.

Key points to remember

  • Face and mouth procedures leave almost invisible scars; body procedures leave real scars, placed in skin folds and covered areas.
  • The worst appearance is at month three. The final appearance is at eighteen months.
  • Three types of care really make a difference: sun protection for a year, silicone for three months, daily massage.
  • Two factors are up to you and weigh more than everything else: do not smoke, and do not put the scar under tension before six weeks.
  • No scar revision is decided before one year.

Frequently asked questions

Does rhinoplasty leave a visible scar?

With the closed approach, the incisions are entirely inside the nostrils: no external scar. With the open approach, a 4 to 5 mm incision crosses the columella, between the nostrils; it becomes almost invisible within a few months and cannot be seen from the front. The choice of approach depends on the work needed, not on a preference for convenience.

Where is the tummy tuck scar?

A low horizontal scar running from hip to hip, positioned to be hidden by standard underwear or a swimsuit, plus a short scar around the repositioned belly button. Its height is discussed before the procedure: bring the most cut-away underwear you wear to the consultation.

What should I put on a scar to make it fade?

Three things work: SPF 50+ sun protection for at least a year, silicone gel or dressings worn 12 to 23 hours a day for 2 to 3 months, and a daily 5 to 10 minute massage from the third week. Topical vitamin E and oils have no proven effect beyond moisturising.

How long until a scar turns white?

Redness starts to fade around the third month, the scar clearly pales between six and twelve months, and its final appearance, pearly white and soft, is reached between twelve and eighteen months. In some areas such as the breastbone or shoulders, it can take two years.

My scar is red and hard at three months, is that serious?

No, this is the normal course. The inflammatory phase, between the third week and the third month, is exactly when the scar is at its reddest, thickest and itchiest. It is also when silicone and massage are most useful. Still, show it at your check-up if it goes beyond the limits of the incision.

Does smoking really damage scars?

Yes, massively. Nicotine narrows small blood vessels and carbon monoxide reduces oxygen transport: the edges of the scar get a poorer blood supply. This leads to delayed healing, a much higher risk of skin tissue death, and wider scars. That is why you are required to stop one month before and one month after the procedure.

This article is written for information purposes and reviewed by Dr. Jed Bouguila (MD-PhD), maxillofacial, plastic and aesthetic surgeon. It describes usual situations and indicative timeframes: it is not a diagnosis, a prescription, or advice tailored to your case. The instructions given by your surgeon and your anaesthetist always take precedence over what is written here. If you have a worrying symptom after surgery, contact your surgical team directly.

Related procedures

Also worth reading

A question about your specific situation?

Timeframes and instructions depend on your anatomy, your medical history and the procedure planned. The pre-operative questionnaire makes it possible to prepare a tailored answer.

Request an opinion